Donald
Arthur Swan (1935-1981)
[28
March 1935. Donald Arthur Swan is born in Jersey City, NJ.
He is the only child of a working-class couple, Arthur James Swan
and Daisy Mae Swan, who had immigrated from Liverpool, England
in 1929. They are relatively old when he is born;
his mother is 32-34 yr. old. The parents divorced when
he was young and he was raised by his mother in Queens Village.
He was precociously intelligent but in poor health (with juvenile-onset
diabetes) and temperamentally difficult.]
[February
1951. Swan enters Queens College at the age of 15.
In a 1987 interview, his mother said sorrowfully that he was "ruined"
by being thrown in with older students. Apparently he did
come into contact with people who influenced his development into
a committed racist.]
[February
1952. Swan is granted "a leave of absence at the request
of the college following numerous incidents involving [Swan] which
resulted in disturbances of the peace on the college campus.
There were conferences between [Swan], his mother and the college
officials as a result of which he went on 'leave'."
He was disciplined for racist and anti-Semitic activity on campus.]
[April
1953. Swan applies for reinstatement at Queens College.]
[May
1953. Swan is informed that he has been granted reinstatement
on probation for the Summer 1953 semester.]
[July
1953. Swan is "again interviewed by the dean
of students [at Queens College] at which conference [Swan] agreed
to discontinue the type of actions which led to his suspension."]
[1954.
Swan graduates from Queens College.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Likes Fascism." Letter.
In Exposé, no. 34 (September 1954), 4.
[This letter sheds unique light on the development
of Swan's political attitudes. In it he calls himself an
"American Fascist."
Exposé was tabloid paper of the publisher
Lyle Stuart. It was established in 1951 and renamed Independent
in 1956. It was published for a while out of Mad
magazine's building. Paul Krassner wrote for it. It
adopted a mildly prurient that rested uneasily with pretensions
to serious muckraking. Its subjects included such things
as sexology, quack health cures, atheism, the Catholic Church,
conspiracies, Nazis, etc. Its masthead said it ran stories
"most papers dare not print."
Swan's letter is a response to a confessional
piece by H. Keith Thompson Jr., a leading American representative
of the Nazi underground, entitled "I Am an American Fascist,"
the first part of which appeared in August issue. On Thompson,
see Martin A. Lee, The Beast Awakens (Boston: Little, Brown,
1997). It is unclear whether Thompson ever had any direct
contact with Swan, but they may have traveled in the same political
circles. Both Swan and Thompson had long relationships with
Willis Carto.
A copy of the issue of Exposé that contains
Swan's letter is in the H. Keith Thompson section of the Hoover
Institution Special Collection Library, Stanford University.
The Hoover Institution's extensive holdings of the Exposé,
as well as of Right, Northern World , and
The Northlander were a gift from Thompson.]
[1954-1955
to 1957. Swan is a graduate student in economics at Columbia
University. He is eventually expelled and denied a degree
after having been found to have stolen many books from the Columbia
library. He later claimed that his treatment by the university
was a case of political persecution.]
[1958.
"En 1958, il avait été nommé expert économique dans un important
cabinet de gestion commerciale" (Nouvelle école).]
1959
[April
1959. In Supreme Court of NY, Queens County, 10 people file a
certificate for incorporation for the Association for the Preservation
of Freedom of Choice (APFC). They include Swan, Alfred Avins,
Henry Garrett, et. al. This group brings together for the
first time some people who will become important racist propagandists
during the 1960s.]
[23
April 1959. The International Association for the Advancement
of Ethnology and Eugenics, Inc., is chartered in Baltimore.
The three incorporators were:
A. James Gregor [q.v.]
Robert E. Kuttner [q.v.]
Lawson Purdy.
Purdy was an eminent old New Yorker. He was a prominent
supporter of Henry George and was Tax Commissioner of the City
of New York, a founder of the National Tax Association, and a
prominent figure in the Charity Organization Society and the City
Club of New York. There were three witnesses to the incorporation:
Donald A. Swan
Arthur J. Swan (his father)
W.J. Neilan (New York lawyer).
The initial officers were:
President:
Robert E. Kuttner
Vice-President: John Brockenbrough Fox
Secretary:
A. James Gregor
Treasurer:
Donald A. Swan.
Fox (born 1916) was a Baltimore attorney. He also served
as IAAEE's initial registered agent. He was the author of
"Morality and the Empire," a letter to the editor of
National Review 7 (August 15, 1959), p. 237, in which he
disputed a claim that had been made in the magazine that Sir Oswald
Mosley's racist solution to "the Notting Hill problem"
was unthinkable and that it would undermine the moral basis of
the Empire. He also wrote a review of Nathaniel Weyl's The
Negro in American Civilization in Mankind Quarterly
1 (January 1961), pp. 223-225. The first issue of Western
Destiny (June 1964) carried an ad for IAAEE that used Fox's
law office for its Treasurer's address.
The notary to the incorporation was Alfred
Avins. The founding members of IAAEE's executive committee
included:
Robert Gayre
R. Ruggles Gates
Henry E. Garrett
Corrado Gini
Charles C. Tansill
Heinrich Quiring.]
[13
May 1959. Supreme Court of NY, Queens County (Shapiro, Judge)
denies approval to APFC's certificate of incorporation.
See 17 Misc. 2d 1012 and 187 NYS 2d 706.]
"Judge
Denies Charter to Hate Group Here." New York Post
(May 14, 1959),
"Freedom
Outfit Biased, Judge Rules." Long Island Press (May
14, 1959),
[16
May 1959. Avins letter to Judge Shapiro.]
[18
May 1959. Judge Shapiro's opinion appears in NY Law Journal,
p 14, col 3.]
[3
June 1959. Neilan and Avins memorandum in support of application.
They send it and a letter to Judge Shapiro on June 4th.]
[16
June 1959. Judge Shapiro tells Neilan, who is trying to
arrange a hearing date, that he is reconsidering his opinion and
that they should follow the NY Law Journal for developments.]
[23
June 1959. Avins, Charles C Tansill and Louis Martin Sears
sign a DC certificate of incorporation for APFC.
Sears (6/4/1885 - 5/14/1960) is the least significant.
At 74, he is a year from death. He also is listed on the
1960 DC certificate of incorporation of the APFC Legal Education
Fund, along with Avins & Sam Crutchfield. He was born
in Chicago & educated at the University of Chicago (A.B. 1905,
A.M. 1909, & Ph.D. 1922). He taught high school in Chicago
as a young man and then spent 36 years on the history faculty
at Purdue University (1920-1956). His books include:
The Puritan and His Indian Wards (1916)
The Middle States & the Embargo of 1808 (1922)
John Slidell (1925)
Purdue University (1925)
Philadelphia and the Embargo of 1808 (1925)
Jefferson & the Embargo (1927)
A History of American Foreign Relations (1927)
American Presidents (1933)
George Washington (1932)
George Washington & the French Revolution (1958).
The APFC certificate listed Sears' address as the Cosmos Club,
Washington, DC (of which Tansill also is a member). He was
an old friend of Tansill & also a defender of the revisionist
historiography of WW1 & WW2 that is associated with Tansill.
See his "Historical Revisionism Following the Two World Wars,"
in Issues & Conflicts: Studies in Twentieth Century American
Diplomacy, ed. George L Anderson, 127-46 (Lawrence: Univ.
of Kansas Press 1959).]
[9
July 1959. Judge Shapiro again denies approval to APFC for
incorporation. See 18 Misc. 2d 534 and 188 NYS 2d 885.]
[14
July 1959. New York Law Journal publishes Shapiro's
second opinion at p. 4, col. 8 and p. 5, cols. 3,4.]
"Charter
Denied to 'Hate' Group." New York Times (July 15,
1959), 12.
"Court
Refuses to Charter Hate Group." New York Post
(July 15, 1959).
"Persecution
of the Right." Right, no. 47 (August 1959):
2.
[Right is a publication
of Willis Carto's group. "No New York Zionist has ever told
the NAACP or the B'nai Brith that it could not promote its peculiar
racial ideals. But Judge Irving Shapiro has just ruled that the
ASSOCIATION FOR FREEDOM OF CHOICE [sic] cannot get a corporate
charter in New York because it is a 'hate group.' Headed by some
brave patriots, the group had intended to promote the ancient
Anglo-Saxon concept of freedom of choice. Thus another sordid
example of Zionist perversion of traditional Nordic-American concepts
of law and individual liberty, to say nothing of legal discrimination
against the White Christian in his 'own' country."]
[7
August 1959. The Association for the Preservation of Freedom of
Choice is incorporated in the District of Columbia.]
[15
August 1959. APFC presents certificate of DC incorporation
for approval in New York.]
[6
October 1959. Court order dismissing Swan's petition in
Swan v. Columbia University.]
[6
October 1959. Judge Shapiro signs order denying approval.]
[22
October 1959. Final order in Swan v. Columbia
University, amending the court's October 6th order.
Denies Swan's application under article 78 of the Civil Practice
Act, dismisses his petition, with $20 costs to the respondent.]
[16
November 1959. Supreme Court of NY, Appellate Division,
2nd Dept., rejects the APFC's appeal of Judge Shapiro's decision.]
"Psychological
Warfare at Work." Review of Brain-Washing: A Synthesis
of the Soviet Textbook on Psychopolitics by Kenneth Goff.
In Northern World 4 (Yule 1959/60): 39-43.
[Roger Pearson established Northern World
in 1956. The present issue, vol. 4, no. 2, is the first one to
list "Edward Langford" rather than Pearson as editor.
This article seems to refer to Swan.
Kenneth Goff was a an ex-communist recruit to the radical right.
He worked for Gerald L.K. Smith and more recently has operated
a church in Colorado. His book was distributed in the UK
by the racist and anti-Semitic Britons Publishing Co., and still
sometimes appears on the reading lists of radical right wing groups.
At p. 39 of the review: "Goff employs the expressive
term 'psychopolitics', and reveals how political propaganda can
be given especial weight and power when aligned with 'mental health'.
Those who accept the required political tenets are then described
as 'socially adjusted' while those who prefer independence of
spirit and mind are labeled as 'mentally ill'..."
At p. 41 the reviewer continues: "...
any individual who revolts against the approved ideologies ...
can be labeled as 'ill-adjusted' to his fellows, or plainly and
simply 'mentally-ill'. An excellent example of this was found
in the schoolboy at Queen's College in America, who founded a
'Nordic League', in what was a racially mixed school. This
youth was promptly handed over to a panel of 'experts', who were
honest enough, in this instance, to admit that he was quite fit,
and after tests actually announced that his I.Q. rating was brilliant."
(Emphasis added.) The schoolboy referred to here almost
certainly was Swan.]
1960
[5
February 1960. Avins letter to New York Secretary of State
Simon, submitting a copy of the APFC's certificate of incorporation
for filing.]
[8
February 1960. Having gotten no response to his February
5th submission to New York Secretary of State Simon, Avins makes
an oral demand for filing at the Secretary of State's NYC office.
The demand is refused.]
[10
February 1960. The APFC initiates a mandamus proceeding
in State Court seeking an order to compel New York Secretary of
State Simon to file its certificate of incorporation, despite
the fact that it lacks approval of a State Supreme Court Justice.]
[12
February 1960. New York Secretary of State Simon issues
a press release on the APFC.]
[May,
Ronald W.] "Draper Grants Adviser Helped Try to Form
N.Y. Hate Group." York Gazette and Daily (March
9, 1960), 1, 18.
[On page 18: "Heading the group
was Donald A. Swan of Queens Village, N.Y., who has described
himself as an 'American Fascist,' according to the New York Post.]
[11
March 1960. Avins, Sam S. Crutchfield and Louis Sears sign
the DC certificate of incorporation for the APFC Legal Education
Fund. Sears, the oldest and least active of the three, dies
within a few months.]
[14
March 1960. DC certificate of incorporation filed for APFC
Legal Education Fund.]
May,
Ronald W. In Capital Times (Madison, Wisconsin),
March 18, 1960
"Books
and Pamphlets on the Right." Right, no. 55 (April
1960): 6.
["The ASSOCIATION FOR THE PRESERVATION OF
FREEDOM OF CHOICE has had reprints made of a 37-page, annotated
article by its counsel [Alfred Avins] titled, 'Anti-Discrimination
Legislation as an Infringement on Freedom of Choice.' First
printed in the New York Law Forum. 25c from Sam Critchfield
[sic], 909 20th St., N.W., Washington 6, D.C."]
[1
April 1960. In the Supreme Court of New York, Special Term,
New York County, Part I, in APFC v. Simon, the court
denies the APFC's petition for an order compelling Simon to file
its certificate of incorporation and hold the statutes to be constitutional.
See 22 Misc. 2d 1016 and 201 NYS 2d 135.]
[18
April 1960. In Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division,
2nd Department, in APFC v. Shapiro, the court denies
the APFC's application for an order directing Judge Shapiro to
reverse his decision and upholds his refusal to sign and approve
its certificate of incorporation. See 202 NYS 2d 218.]
May,
Ronald. "Genetics and Subversion." Nation
190 (May 14, 1960): 420-422.
[On page 422 May writes: "... Garrett
... was one of a group of New Yorkers who a year ago sought a
certificate of incorporation from the Queens County, N.Y., Supreme
Court to form an 'Association for the Preservation of Freedom
of Choice.' Heading the petitioners was Donald A. Swan,
whom the New York Post has referred to as a 'self-described
American Fascist'."]
[14
May 1960. Louis Martin Sears, a DC incorporator of the APFC
and the APFC Legal Education Fund, dies.]
[26
May 1960. In the Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division,
1st Department, in Swan v. Columbia University,
the court accepts Swan's appeal. See 10 AD 2d 942 and 205
NYS 2d 03.]
[30
(or 3) May 1960. Action commenced in APFC and Donald
Swan v. New York Post.]
[21
June 1960. In Supreme Court of NY, Appellate Division, 1st
Department, in Swan v. Columbia University, the
court unanimously upholds lower court's order dismissing Swan's
petition. See 11 AD 2d 670.]
[July
1960. The first issue of Mankind Quarterly is published.]
[August
1960. Letter from Swan to Dr. J.M. Tabb of the Mississippi
Department of Education, proposing that the Mississippi Department
of Education purchase subscriptions to Mankind Quarterly
for distribution to state educators and school superintendents.]
[14
September 1960. Letter from Dr. J.M. Tabb to Swan, indicating
that he has passed Swan's request for subscriptions to Mankind
Quarterly along to Ada Sumrall, the Library Supervisor for
the Mississippi Department of Education.]
1961
[20
February 1961. Arguments are heard in the cases of APFC
v. Shapiro and APFC v. Simon.]
[14
March 1961. The Court of Claims dismisses APFC v
State of New York. See 26 Misc. 2d 929.]
[30
March 1961. The Court of Appeals of New York reaches decisions
in the cases of APFC v. Shapiro and APFC
v. Simon. See 9 NYS 2d 376.]
[31
March 1961. In the Supreme Court of New York, Appellate
Division, 1st Department, motions are filed in the cases of APFC
v. The Nation Associates and APFC v. Kirstein.
See 13 AD 2d 493.]
Wesley,
David. Hate Groups and the Un-American Activities Committee.
New York: Emergency Civil Liberties Committee, 1961.
[This pamphlet was published on April 3,
1961. It included a discussion of the APFC and gave rise
to a libel action. A 2nd revised edition appeared in 1962.]
[6
June 1961. In the case of APFC v. The Nation Associates,
the Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division, 1st Department,
denies motion to add appeal to its calendar.]
[8
June 1961. Letter from Swan to Ada Sumrall (Mississippi
State Department of Education). "Dr. A. James Gregor
(see enclosed photostat of article entitled 'On the Nature of
Prejudice') and I will make a two-week trip in July through several
of the Southern states in order to discuss educational projects
in the fields of race and race relations with state educational
officials. If it would be convenient for you, we would like
to get together with you and any other interested officials at
that time."]
[9
June 1961. In the case of APFC v. Dudley,
the Supreme Court of New York, Special Term, New York County,
dismisses the APFC's petition seeking to annul the New York State
Commission Against Discrimination's dismissal of the APFC's complaint
alleging an unlawful conspiracy to foist a Negro President on
the Borough of Manhattan. See 29 Misc. 2d 710 and 222 NYS
2d 631.]
[12
July 1961. In US District Court for the Southern District
of New York (Thomas Murphy, D.J.), APFC v. Simon
is initiated by filing and service of summons and complaint.]
[27
July 1961. Notice to Avins of a motion to dismiss the complaint
against Simon.]
[1
August 1961. Alfred Avins files a motion requesting a three-judge
panel in APFC v. Simon.]
[9
August 1961. US District Court Judge Thomas Murphy denies
the APFC's motion requesting that APFC v. Simon
be heard by a three-judge panel.]
[15
August 1961. In US District Court, Southern District of New York
(Thomas Murphy, District Judge), in APFC v. Simon,
the defendant moves to dismiss and the plaintiff cross-moves for
summary judgment.]
Comas,
Juan. "'Scientific' Racism Again?" Current
Anthropology 2 (October 1961): 303-340.
[9
October 1961. In US District Court, Southern District of
New York (Thomas Murphy, District Judge), in APFC and APFC
Legal Education Fund v. Simon, the court dismisses
the complaint.]
[31
October 1961. The Supreme Court of New York, Special Term,
New York County, Part I. APFC and Swan v. Pickering.
See 226 NYS 2d 857 and 31 Misc. 2d 847.]
[8
November 1961. APFC and APFC Legal Education Fund
v. Simon. Notice of appeal from US District Court
to the US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit.]
[7
December 1961. In APFC and APFC Legal Education Fund
v Simon, Avins files Brief for Appellants with US Court
of Appeals, 2nd Circuit.]
[8
December 1961. Order of the Appellate Division in APFC
and Donald Swan v. Kirstein and the Nation Company.]
[14
December 1961. The Court of Claims dismisses the complaint
in APFC v. State of New York. (See 14 March
1961.) See 30 Misc. 2d 808.]
1962
[15
January 1962. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit gets and
files the Defendant-Appelle's Appendix in APFC & APFC Legal
Education Fund v. Simon.]
[18
January 1962. Complaint is filed in US District Court, Southern
District of Georgia, in Stell v. Savannah-Chatham County
Board of Education.]
[19
January 1962. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit. Arguments
in APFC v. Wagner and APFC v. Simon.]
[6
February 1962. Motion in APFC v. Kirstein
and APFC v. Nation Associates, Inc.]
[6
February 1962. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit, dismisses
appeals in APFC v. Wagner (see 298 F2d 522) and
APFC v. Simon (see 299 F2d 212).]
Swan,
Donald A. "Juan Comas on ''Scientific' Racism Again?':
A Scientific Analysis." Mankind Quarterly 2
(April-June 1962): 231-45.
[This was Swan's first article in Mankind Quarterly.
He had just turned 27.]
Reuning,
Helmut. "Psychological Tests of the Kalahari Bushmen."
Mankind Quarterly 2 (April-June 1962): 265-73.
[Translated from the German by Swan. Reuning
(b. 1914 in SW Africa), was educated in Germany and fought in
Wehrmaht on the Eastern Front during World War II. Beginning
in 1952 he worked at the National Institute for Personnel Research
in South Africa, where he was coeditor of its journal, Psychologia
Africana. He was associated with the International
Association for the Advancement of Ethnology and Eugenics.]
Lundman,
Bertil. "Race, Language, and the History of Peoples."
Mankind Quarterly 2 (April-June 1962): 274-79.
[Translated from German by Swan.]
[3
May 1962. Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County,
Part 1. APFC and Swan v. NY Post Corporation.
See 228 N.Y.S.2d 767 and 35 Misc. 2d 65.]
[3
May 62. Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County, Part
1. APFC and Swan and Avins v. Nation Co.
See 228 N.Y.S.2d 628 and 35 Misc. 2d 42.]
[22
June 1962. Plaintiff's motion number 15 in APFC and Swan
v. Kirstein and the Nation.]
[25
June 1962. Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County,
denies a motion for renewal in APFC v. New York Post.]
[July-Sept
62. Mankind Qtrly, vol. 3, no. 1. This was
the first issue to list Swan as an Assistant Editor (with Robert
E. Kuttner and A. James Gregor).]
[3
July 1962. Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County,
Part 1. In APFC and Swan v. Kirstein and the Nation
Co, the court denies Avins' motion for summary judgment and
grants defendants' motion to dismiss the cause of action on behalf
of the corporate plaintiff. See 231 N.Y.S.2d 937.]
[19
July 1962. Donald Swan commences an action against the Board
of Higher Education of the City of New York, in New York Supreme
Court, County of New York. The action is based on the treatmetn
Swan received while at Queens College. The court eventually
grants a motion to dismiss the action.]
[20
July 1962. Donald Swan commences a second action against the Board
of Higher Education of the City of New York, this one in US District
Court for the Southern District of New York.]
[14
August 1962. In the action Swan commenced in US District
Court (S.D.N.Y.) on 20 July, the Board of Higher Education of
the City of New York moves to have Swan's complaint dismissed.]
[22
August 1962. New York Law Journal, p 7. Opinion
of Justice Amsterdam (New York State Supreme Court, County of
New York) dismissing APFC Legal Education Fund and Swan
v. Gustave G Rosenberg, as Chairman of the Board of Higher
Education of the City of New York (Index no. 12274/1962).]
[23
August 1962. Swan v. Board of Higher Education
of the City of New York, et. al. (Index no. 14473/1962) is
filed in New York State Supreme Court, New York County.
It is eventually dismissed.]
[10
September 1962. In US District Court, Southern District
of New York (Metzner, District Judge), in Swan v. Board
of Higher Education of the City of New York, the Federal action
Swan commenced on July 20th, the court dismisses the complaint
as barred by the statute of limitations.]
[~13
September 1962. An amended complaint filed in Swan
v. Board of Higher Education, without having obtained the
leave of the court to do so. (This is a procedural error.)]
[14
September 1962. An amended complaint is served in APFC
v. Emergency Civil Liberties Committee.]
[17
September 1962. In Swan v. Board of Higher Education,
an attorney for Board of Higher Education returns the amended
complaint he has been served. He indicates that since no
leave of the court had been obtained, he would treat the complaint
as a nullity.]
[19
October 1962. In the Federal action, Swan v. Board
of Higher Education, that Swan had commenced in US District
Court (Southern District of New York) on July 20th, the Court
(Metzner, D.J.) grants a motion for reargument of the September
10th order dismissing the complaint.]
[9
November 1962. In the action that Swan had commenced in
US District Court (S.D.N.Y.) on July 20th, he serves notice of
a motion returnable on November 20th seeking a default judgment
against the Board of Higher Education for failing to respond to
the amended complaint served on September 17th.]
[26
November 1962. In the action Swan commenced in US District
Court (S.D.N.Y.) on July 20th, the Court denies Swan's November
9th motion for a default judgment against Board of HigherEducation
for failing to respond to the amended complaint that was served
on September 17th.]
[6
December 1962. In US District Court for the Southern District
of New York (Metzner, District Judge), in Swan v. Board
of Higher Education, after reargument the court announces
that it will continue to adhere to its September 10th decision.]
[11
December 1962. Supreme Courtt, Special Term, County of New
York. APFC, et al v. Emergency Civil Liberties
Committee. See 236 NYS 2d 216 and 37 Misc. 2d 599.]
[28
December 1962. Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Div,
3rd Department, affirms the lower court's order in APFC
v. State of New York. See 18 AD 2d 747.]
[~1962.
Symposium on Anti-Discrimination Legislation, Freedom of Choice,
and Property Rights in Housing, organized by Alfred Avins, who
intended to publish its proceedings in the April 1963 issue
of the Chicago-Kent Law Review, of which he was faculty
editor. Ultimately the university administration objected
to his use of the journal as a platform for his racial views and
the symposium papers had to be published elsewhere.]
1963
[22
January 1963. Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division,
1st Department, renders a decision in APFC v. The Nation,
APFC v. Kirstein, and APFC v. Pickering.
It grants a motion to dismiss the appeal in each action.
See 18 AD2d 791.]
[31
January 1963. Motion to intervene in Stell v. Savannah.]
[11
March 1963. The first instance of mail fraud for which Swan
eventually serves time in prison.]
[18
March 1963. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit, gets a Brief
of Defendants-Appelles in Swan v. Board of Higher Education.]
[26
March 1963. The second instance of mail fraud of which Swan
is convicted in 1967.]
[6
May 1963. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit, hears arguments
in Swan v. Board of Higher Education.]
[28
May 1963. Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division,
1st Department, affirms the lower court's decision dismissing
APFC v. New York Post. See 19 AD2d 528.]
[29
May 63. Supplemental Brief and Argument in Support of Motion
to Intervene, in Stell v. Savannah.]
[May
1963. Hearing in Stell.]
[4
June 1963. US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit, renders a decision
in Swan v. Board of Higher Education of the City of
NY.]
[28
June 1963. Stell v. Savannah. In US District
Court for the Southern District of Georgia, District Judge Frank
M Scarlett enters a final opinion and judgment.]
Lundman,
Bertil. Review of The Island Civilization of Polynesia
by Robert G. Suggs. In Mankind Quarterly 4 (July-September
1963): 57.
[Translated by Swan.]
Lundman,
Bertil. Review of Le Razze e l'Popoli della Terra
by Renato Biasutti. In Mankind Quarterly 4 (July-September
1963): 60.
[Translated by Swan.]
1964
Lundman,
Bertil. "Professor Egon von Eickstedt: World-Renowned
Anthropologist." Mankind Quarterly 4 (January-March
1964): 161-64.
[Translated by Swan.]
[20
January 1964. Arguments before 5th Circuit Court of Appeals
in Brown v. Charleston.]
[27
January 1964. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals hands down
its decision in Brown v. Charleston.]
[Feb
1964. The Anatomy of a Controversy, Part III. Mankind Monographs
VI. Edinburgh: Mankind Quarterly. Includes reprint of Swan,
"Juan Comas on ''Scientific' Racism Again?': A Scientific
Analysis."]
Swan,
Donald A. "Human Genetics and Psychological Differences."
Mankind Quarterly 4 (April- June 1964): 197-201.
Miszkiewicz,
Brunon. "The Anthropological Structure of the Population
of Schwalm." Mankind Quarterly 4 (April-June 1964):
211-213.
[Translated by Swan from the German. The original
appeared as "Die anthropologische Struktur der Bevölkerung
aus der Schwalm" in Homo 12 (1961): 129-31.
Swan established a relationship with Miszkiewicz that continues
until his death. He translated a number of Miszkiewicz's
papers (originally published in Homo) for Mankind Quarterly
and in the mid-1970s Miszkiewicz cames to Hattiesburg to collaborate
with Swan on a research project.]
[18-21
May 1964. US District court hears Evers v. Jackson
and related cases. R. Travis Osborne, Henry Garrett, Frank
McGurk, Ernest van den Haag, and Robert Kuttner testified. Wesley
Critz George had been scheduled to testify, but was unable to
be present due to his wife's illness. William E Hoy was
also present.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Genetics and Psychology." Genus
20 (1964): 23-35.
[18
June 1964. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals hands down
a decision overturning District Judge Scarlett in Stell
v. Savannah.]
Males,
Branimiro. "Racial Biodynamics and Biogenesis in the
Study of Population." Mankind Quarterly 5 (July-September
1964): 3-20.
[Translated from Spanish by Swan.]
Wintringer,
Gerard. "The Intelligence of the African Negro." Mankind
Quarterly 4 (July-September 1964): 35-44.
[Translated by Swan from "Considérations
sur l'intelligence du Noir africain," Revue de Psychologie
des Peuples 10 (1955): 37-55.]
[6
or 7 July 1964. The US District Court hands down its decision
in Evers v Jackson.]
[23
July 1964. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals denies a rehearing
in Stell v Savannah.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Biological Processes of Race Formation."
Mankind Quarterly 5 (October- December 1964): 110-116.
[2
October 1964. Swan mails a postcard fraudulently ordering
merchandise from Lee and Febiger Publishers, Philadelphia.
This is the basis of the fourth count in the fraud charge against
him.]
[12
October 1964. The US Supreme Court rejects appeal in Brown
v. Charleston without comment. This is the first
time any of this group of cases has gotten to Supreme Court; it
marks the end of the process.]
[5
November 1964. Date on a letter from Swan ordering books
from Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago. This is the
basis of the fifth count in the fraud charge against him.]
[10
November 1964. Date of a letter from Swan ordering books
from Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago. This is the
basis of the sixth count in fraud charge against him.]
1965
Swan,
Donald A. "Racial Differences and Physical Anthropology."
Mankind Quarterly 5 (January-February 1965): 149-160.
[1
February 1965. Swan's friend and co-conspirator in mail
fraud, Andrew Portoghese, tells a business associate, Max Meyer,
that a Dr. David Levy is going away and needs someone to accept
his mail until he returns. Meyer agrees to accept
mail addressed to Levy at his business.]
[10
February 1965. Using a newspaper clipping, Swan orders
merchandise from The Classics Club, Roslyn, Long Island.
This leads to the 7th count of mail fraud.]
[11
February 1965. Basis of the 8th mail fraud count against
Swan.]
[17
February 1965. Swan mails a magazine mail order form to
Classics Record Library, NY, using name "Dr David Levy"
and the address of Max Meyer, Inc. This is the basis of
the 9th mail fraud count against Swan and Portoghese.]
[28
March 1965. Basis for the 10th mail fraud count against
Swan. This was also his 30th birthday.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "A Rorschach Study of the Development
of Personality Structure in White and Negro Children in a Southeastern
Community" by A.C. Price. In Homo 16 (1965):
50-52.
[This reviews an article published in Genetic
Psychology Monographs 65 (1962): 3-52.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Race and Mental Differences."
Mankind Quarterly 5 (April-June 1965): 196-203.
Swan,
Donald A. "Race, Selection, and Psychical Traits."
Mankind Quarterly 5 (April-June 1965): 206-211.
[5
April 1965. Basis for 11th mail fraud count against Swan.]
Swan,
Donald A., and H.M. Roland. "Race, Psychology and
Education: Wilmington, North Carolina." Mankind
Quarterly 6 (July-September 1965): 19-36.
[This was Swan's last item in Mankind
Qtrly before his arrest. He didn't publish there again
for more than six years, until 1971.]
[15
December 1965. Basis for the 12th and last mail fraud count
against Swan.]
1966
Leonard,
George Stephen. "Ethnic Differentiation in the United
States School Desegregation Cases." Mankind Quarterly
6 (January-March 1966): 139-148.
[See notes on Leonard. At 144 he writes:
"In this same period [after Brown] outside the courts
a considerable body of evidence was being assembled that announced
conclusions of our Supreme Court were scientifically incorrect
and that a demonstration could be made to show not only that the
races differ basically in their learning patterns and average
intelligence but that this conclusion was supported by the published
studies on comparative brain weight and structure and by data
from the fields of differential psychology and the newer discipline
of social dynamics. Directly concerned with ... bringing
together the available scientific materials which contradicted
the assertions of Drs Redfield & Clark were a number of scientists
and others well known to the readers of The Mankind Quarterly,
including Drs Garrett, George, Armstrong, Osborne, van den Haag,
Kuttner, Gregor; and much of the credit for collating &
organizing the available data belongs to an Assistant Editor,
Donald A. Swan."]
[January-March
1966. Mankind Qtrly, vol. 6, no. 3. This is
the last issue to list Swan as an assistant editor. His
name was removed from the masthead after his April 1966 arrest.]
[26
January 1966. The US Court of Appeals (5th Circuit) decision
in Evers v Jackson.]
[28
March 1966. Swan's 31st birthday.]
[5
April 1966. Swan is arrested.]
Walsh,
Robert. "Probe PO Fraud, Find Arms Cache."
New York Daily News (April 6, 1966), 5.
"Anti-Semitic
Tracts Found at Home of New Yorker Arrested for Fraud."
Jewish Telegraphic Agency Daily News Bulletin (April 7,
1966), 4.
[14
May 1966. The US Court of Appeals (5th Circuit) denies certiorari
in Evers v Jackson.]
[9
August 1966. The US House passes the proposed Civil Rights
Act of 1966.]
[6-19
September 1966. The US Senate debates the Civil Rights Act
of 1966. The bill dies after filibuster.]
[14
September 1966. Cloture is voted down in the Senate.
Five days later supporters of the bill again fail to obtain cloture
and the bill dies.]
1967
Kuttner,
Robert E., editor. Race and Modern Science. New York:
Social Science Press, 1967.
[At various periods during in the preparation
of the book, both Swan and A. James Gregor were considered as
editors. Swan was ruled out after his arrest late during
the preparation process.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Selected Pupil and School Characteristics."
Tydskrif vir Rasse- Aangeleenthede / Journal of Racial Affairs
18 (January 1967): 28-36.
[This is the first of three papers by Swan published
here in interim between his arrest and sentencing. The journal
is published by the Suid-Afrikaanse Buro Vir Rasse-Aangeleenthede,
in Stellenbosch, near Cape Town.]
[24
January 1967. Psychological Reports accepts Kuttner,
Lorincz and Swan, "The Schizophrenia Gene and Social Evolution."]
Kuttner,
Robert E., Albert B. Lorincz, and Donald A. Swan. "The
Schizophrenia Gene and Social Evolution." Psychological
Reports 20 (April 1967): 407-412.
[Lorincz is a colleague of Kuttner [q.v.].]
Swan,
Donald A. "Comparison of the Relation Between Mental
Maturity and Academic Achievement Among White and Negro School
Children in a South Louisiana Parish." Tydskrif
vir Rasse-Aangeleenthede / Journal of Racial Affairs 18 (April
1967): 89-107.
[The data were collected in Fall 1963.]
[16-21
August 1967. Swan's mail fraud trial is held in US District
Court in New York.]
[17
August 1967. On the second day of the trial, Swan's co-defendant,
Andrew Portoghese, pleads guilty to one count (count 7) of the
indictment and agrees to testify against Swan.]
[22
September 1967. US District Court Judge Jacob Mishler sentences
Swan for "study and report."]
1968
Swan,
Donald A. "Race, Psychology and Socio-Economic Achievement."
Tydskrif vir Rasse-Aangeleenthede / Journal of Racial Affairs
18 (January 1968): 3-10.
[5
January 1968. US District Court Judge Jacob Mishler resentences
Swan to three years. Swan appeals to the US Court of Appeals,
2nd Circuit.]
[1
March 1968. Swan's lawyer files a Brief and Appendix for
the Appellant with the US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit.]
[21
March 1968. The US Attorney for the Eastern District of
New York files an Appellee's Brief with the US Court of Appeals,
2nd District, in Swan's appeal of his mail fraud conviction.]
[10
April 1968. Arguments before US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit,
in Swan's appeal of his mail fraud conviction.]
[3
June 1968. The US Court of Appeals, 2nd Circuit, affirms
Swan's mail fraud conviction.]
[13
June 1968. Date on Swan's petition to the US Court of Appeals,
2nd Circuit, for a rehearing and rehearing before the Court in
banc. The Court Clerk marks it "filed" 5 days
later.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Le processes biologique de la formation
raciale." Nouvelle Ecole, no. 3 (June-July 1968):
11-17.
[The theme for this issue is "Anthropology."
Four articles by Swan are its centerpiece. (They first appeared
in Mankind Quarterly, vol. 5, October-December 1964 to
April-June 1965, and are theoretical papers summarizing the racial
theory he had worked out at the time of his arrest.)
It is noteworthy that these papers appeared
so prominently at this moment, in the issue of Nouvelle école
that was produced during the May events of 1968.
In its obituary of him, Nouvelle école
says that Swan "suivant les activités de Nouvelle école
depuis le premier numéro," i.e., since February-March 1968.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Différenciation raciale et anthropologie
physique." Nouvelle Ecole, no. 3 (June-July
1968): 18-30.
Swan,
Donald A. "Race, sélection et caractères psychiques."
Nouvelle Ecole, no. 3 (June-July 1968): 31-36.
Swan,
Donald A. "Race et psychologie." Nouvelle
Ecole, no. 3 (June-July 1968): 37-45.
1971
[1971.
Swan receives an M.A. degree in mathematics from Hunter College.]
Swan,
Donald A. "C-14 und die Vorgeschichte Europas."
Mannus: Zeitschrift für Deutsche Vorgeschichte 37
(1971): 48-53.
[An English version appears as "Carbon-14
and the Prehistory of Europe: A Review of the Revised Data"
in Mankind Quarterly 12 (January-March 1972)
This was Swan's first publication in Mannus;
he continued to be associated with it until his death. It
is published in Bonn in association with the Gesellschaft für
Vor- und Frügeschichte by Dieter Korell (Hückeswagen). It
was a marginal journal that defended the ideas of the German prehistorians
of the Nazi era. For general background see:
WJ McCann (Department of German, University
of Southampton), "'Volk und Germanentum': The Presentation
of the Past in Nazi Germany," in The Politics of the Past,
edited by Peter Gathercole and David Lowenthal, 74-88. One World
Archaeology Series vol. 12, London: Unwin Hyman, 1990
Bettina Arnold (Department of Anthropology,
Harvard), "The Past as Propaganda: Totalitarian Archaeology
in Nazi Germany," Antiquity 64 (September 1990): 464-78
Ulrich Veit (University of Münster), "Ethnic
Concepts in German Prehistory: A Case Study on the Relationship
Between Cultural Identity and Archaeological Objectivity,"
in Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity, edited
by SJ Shennan, 35-56, One World Archaeology Series, London: Unwin
Hyman 1990
Jes Martens (Denmark), "The Vandals: Myths
and Facts About the Germanic Tribe of the 1st Half of the 1st
Millennium AD, in Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity,
edited by SJ Shennan, 57-65, One World Archaeology Series, London:
Unwin Hyman 1990
Bettina Arnold, "The Past as Propaganda:
How Hitler's Archaeologists Distorted European Prehistory to Justify
Racist and Territorial Goals," Archaeology 45 (July-August
1992): 30-37]
[Fall
1971. Roger Pearson returns to the University of Southern
Mississippi in Hattiesburg. He hires Swan and Robert Kuttner
as members of the faculty.]
Swan,
Donald A. "The American School of Ethnology."
Mankind Quarterly 12 (October- December 1971): 78-98.
[This and the following are Swan's first
contributions to Mankind Quarterly in more than six years,
since before his 1966 arrest.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of Multivariate Procedures for the Behavioral
Sciences by W.W. Cooley and P.R. Lohnes. In Mankind
Quarterly 12 (October-December 1971): 121.
Swan,
Donald A. Letter. Atlantic Monthly 228 (December
1971): 106.
[An endorsement of R.J. Herrnstein's "I.Q."
(September 1971). Swan gives the IAAEE as his affiliation.]
1972
Swan,
Donald A. "Carbon-14 and the Prehistory of Europe:
A Review of the Revised Data." Mankind Quarterly
12 (January-March 1972): 138-43.
[The German version was in Mannus 1971.]
Richthofen,
Bolko, Freiherr von. Review of Geistesgeschichte der
Frühzeit by Friedrich Cornelius. In Mannus 38
(1972): 49-52.
[Richthofen [q.v.] was a leading Nazi prehistorian.]
Lundman,
Bertil. "Anthropological, Sociological and Psychological
Investigations of Swedish School Children." Mankind
Quarterly 12 (April-June 1972): 189-212.
[Translated from the German by Swan.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Blood Type Gene Frequency and
Mental Ability" by R. Travis Osborne and D.E. Suddick.
In Mankind Quarterly 12 (April-June 1972): 244.
[A German translation appears in Mannus
1973.]
[1972.
Swan receives an M.A. degree from New York University.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of Geographische Anthropologie by
Bertil Lundman. In Nouvelle Ecole, no. 18 (May-June
1972): 74.
[29
July 1972. Annual meeting of the Gesellschaft für Vor- und
Frügeschichte, in Krems an der Donau, Lower Austria. In
a report on the meeting in Mannus, vol. 39, no. 1 (1973),
page 69, Dieter Korell writes: "Von den überseeischen
Ländern sind unsere Beziehungen besonders gut in die USA.
Wie Sie wissen, ist Prof. Swan der City-University New York Korrespondierendes
Mitglied unserer Gesellschaft. In nächster Zeit wird er
noch intensiver am Mannus mitarbeiten, wahrscheinlich sogar redaktionell
tätig sein. Die führenden Universitäten der USA beziehen
den Mannus, übrigens auch die Kongreß-Bibliothek in Washington.
Diese Verbindungen werden ständig intensiviert und zeitigen schon
jetzt gute Früchte."]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "The Origin of Man" by Grover
S. Krantz. In Mannus 38 (1972): 241-242.
Swan,
Donald A. "Zur Entwicklung der Menschlichen Gehirnkapazität."
Mannus 38 (1972): 257-64.
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Social Class, Race, Seriating
and Reading Readiness: A Study of Their Relationship at the Kindergarten
Level" by Ralph Scott. In Nouvelle Ecole, no.
21-22 (Winter 1972-73): 131-33.
[See the references to Scott below.]
[1972-81.
Mannus: Swan is Mitglieder der Schriftleitung from
v 38 n 4 (last issue for 1972) until his death.]
1973
Swan,
Donald A. "The Measurement of Cultural Development
in the Ancient Near East and in Anglo-Saxon England."
Mankind Quarterly 13 (January-March 1973): 166-170.
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "IQs of Identical Twins Raised
Apart" by Arthur R. Jensen. In Mankind Quarterly
13 (January-March 1973): 187-88.
Swan,
Donald A. "Differences in Races Are Not Just Skin
Deep." Pulse (January 20, 1973): 20-21.
[Pulse was a popular British medical
paper. It also published material by Dr. Robert John.
This article was reprinted in Swan, "Racial Differences Are
Not Just Skin Deep," American Mercury, no. 528 (Spring
1978): 30-34. It and the following were distributed by the
IAAEE and more recently by Robert John's International Council
for Human Ecology and Ethnology.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Race Shows in IQ Tests." Pulse
(January 27, 1973): 18.
[Cited in Barry Mehler, "The New Eugenics:
Academic Racism in the U.S. Today," Science for the People
15 (May-June 1983): 18-23.]
Swan,
Donald A. "The Anthropology of the Brain: 3.
Homo Erectus, the Origin of Races, and the Evolution of the Brain."
Mankind Quarterly 14 (July-September 1973): 3-40.
Swan,
Donald A., and Dieter Korell. "Bemerkungen zu Homo
Erectus, dem Ursprung der Rassen, und der Entwicklung des menschlichen
Gehirns." Mannus 39 (1973): 135-178.
[Korell is the editor of Mannus.]
Swan,
Donald A., and Frank Miele, with the assistance of R. Travis Osborne.
"A Factor Analysis of Oetteking's Ancient Egyptian Cranial
Data." Homo 24 (1973): 188-204.
Swan,
Donald A. "Professor Henry E. Garrett: 1894-1973."
Mankind Quarterly 14 (October-December 1973): 83-84.
Swan,
Donald A. "Brain Weight of Danes: A Review."
Mankind Quarterly 14 (October- December 1973): 85-92.
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Blood Type Gene Frequency and
Mental Ability" by R. Travis Osborne and D.E. Suddick.
In Mannus 39 (1973): 349-50.
[In German. The English original appeared
in Mankind Quarterly (April-June 1972). Swan thanked
Leo Büchler (Hückeswagen) for help with the translation.
Swan is listed at page 350 among Mitarbeiter for volume 39 (1973).]
1974
Swan,
Donald A. "The Anthropology of the Brain: 4.
The Evolution of the Neanderthal Brain.- Part I." Mankind
Quarterly 14 (January-March 1974): 123-55.
Swan,
Donald A. "The Anthropology of the Brain: 4.
The Evolution of the Neanderthal Brain.- Part II."
Mankind Quarterly 14 (April-May 1974): 185-208.
[Spring
1974. Roger Pearson's last semester in Hattiesburg.
He went to Butte, Montana for a year and then to Washington DC.
Swan stayed behind in Hattiesburg.]
Kuttner,
Robert E., and Donald A. Swan. "Biological Aspects
of Human Cultural Evolution." Southern Quarterly
12 (July 1974): 323-333.
[Kuttner is listed as associate professor of anthropology.
This journal is published by the University of Southern Mississippi.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Neue Endokraniale Werte für Australopithrcinen"
by Ralph L. Holloway. In Mannus 40 (1974):
85-86.
Lundman,
Bertil. "The Races and Peoples of North and Central Asia."
Mankind Quarterly 15 (October-December 1974): 92-99.
[Translated by Swan.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Brain Evolution: New Light on
Old Principles" by Harry J. Jerison. In Mankind
Quarterly 15 (October-December 1974): 149-50.
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Social Class, Race, Seriating
and Reading Readiness" by Ralph Scott. In Mankind
Quarterly 15 (October-December 1974): 153-54.
Swan,
Donald A. "Rassenzugehörigkeit und Intelligenz."
Nation Europa 24 (November 1974): 37-40.
1975
Miszkiewicz,
Brunon. "The Anthropology of the Aunjetitz Population
of Tomice, Poland." Mankind Quarterly 15 (April-June
1975): 281-92.
[Translated by Swan from "Die Aunjetitzer
Bevölkerung aus Tomice, Kr. Dzieróoniòw" Homo 23 (1972):
145-54]
Boev,
Peter. "Anthropological Data on the Ethnogenesis of
the Ancient Thracians." Mankind Quarterly 16
(July-September 1975): 68-73.
[Translated by Swan from "Anthropologische
Angaben über die Ethnogenese der Thraker" Homo 21
(1970): 94-97. Swan translated a second article by Boev
in Mankind Quarterly, 1980. Boev, Bulgarian physical
anthropologist, was on Mankind Quarterly's Editorial Advisory
Board for a long time; since vol. 34, no. 3 (Spring 1994),
he has been a member of its Editorial Committee.]
Miszkiewicz,
Brunon. "The Anthropological Structure of the North
Frisian Population." Mankind Quarterly
16 (October-December 75): 104-
[Translated by Swan from "Die anthropologische
Struktur der Nordfriesen," Homo 14 (1963): 48-52.]
Swan,
Donald A. "On the Question of Mongoloid Admixture Among
the Ancient Slavs." Review of "Zur Frage Mongolider
Beimischung bei den Altslawen" by Ilse Schwidetzky.
In Mankind Quarterly 16 (October-December 1975):
143-47.
[Schwidetzky's article appeared in Anthropologische
Anzeiger 29 (1965): 226-33.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "Social Class, Race, Seriating
and Reading Readiness" by Ralph Scott. In Mankind
Quarterly 16 (October-December 1975): 148-50.
[Fall
1975. Swan initiates an anthropological & psychometric
study of Anglo-Saxon children in South Mississippi. The
psychometric work is directed by Ralph Scott [q.v.]. This
is around the time of some of Scott's most controversial political
activities. Scott is also getting separate grants from Pioneer
Fund for other projects.) "Anthropometric data (head
and body measurements), pigmentation measures, dermatoglyphic
data, serological data, and measures of intelligence and personality
were obtained from more than 1,000 students at three private academies
in the South Mississippi area ... " The schools are
segregationist academies in three towns near Hattiesburg:
Columbia Academy, Sanford Academy, and Brookhaven Academy.]
[November-December
1975. As part of Swan's study of South Mississippi Anglo-Saxon
school children, anthropometric measurements are made of students
at Columbia Academy. Data on family size and ordinal position
are also gathered.]
Swan,
Donald A. Review of "On the Evolution of Tool-Using
Behaviour" by Jane B Lancaster. In Nouvelle Ecole,
no. 27-28 (Autumn-Winter 1975): 151-53.
1976
Swan,
Donald A. "Psychological Studies on the Sudanese and
Guinean Negroes." Mankind Quarterly 16 (January-March
1976): 163-98.
Lipták,
Pal. "The Anthropological Find from the Szabadszallas-Boczka
Estate in Hungary." Mankind Quarterly 16 (January-March
1976): 214-18.
[Translated from German by Swan. Lipták is in
Szeged, Hungary.]
[January
1976. As part of Swan's study of south Mississippi Anglo-Saxon
schoolchildren, David Stephen Engelstad, one of Ralph Scott's
graduate students, administers IQ tests to 498 children (grades
K through 12) at Columbia Academy.]
Lundman,
Bertil. "The Distribution of Anthropological Traits
in Europe." Mankind Quarterly 16 (April-June
1976): 257-78.
[Translated from German by Swan.]
[April
1976. Ralph Scott's graduate students administer personality
questionnaires: David Engelstad at Columbia Academy and
Bryce Kim at Sanford Academy.]
[1
October 1976. The Pioneer Fund approves a $2,000 grant to
the IAAEE "for the study of American Anglo-Saxon school children."
(Pioneer Fund's 1976 Form 990. IAAEE's address is PO Box
1588, Southern Station, Hattiesburg.)]
[October
1976. Patrick Mooney, a graduate student of Ralph Scott,
administers personality questionnaires at Brookhaven Academy.]
Lundman,
Bertil. "The Racial History of Europe: An Outline."
Mankind Quarterly 17 (October- December 1976): 115-29.
[Translated from German by Swan.]
1977
Hébert,
Jean-Pierre. Race et Intelligence. Paris: Editions
Copernic, 1977.
[This is the first volume of Factuelles, a series
produced under the direction of Alain de Benoist. It has well-informed,
extensive references to Swan's work.]
Swan,
Donald A. "Ales Hrdlicka on Race Deterioration and
Race Destruction." Mankind Quarterly 17 (January-March
1977): 201-207.
[31
January 1977. The Pioneer Fund approves a $5,000 grant to
the IAAEE "for the study of American Anglo-Saxon school children."
The same day, it approves a $4,000 grant to the IAAEE "for
the reprint of a monograph on Heredity & Eugenics. $4,000
expended per report dated 9/28/77/." (Pioneer Fund's 1977
Form 990. IAAEE's address remains PO Box 1588, Southern
Station, Hattiesburg.)]
Swan,
Donald A. "Sir Grafton Elliot Smith on 'The Negro Race'."
Mankind Quarterly 17 (April-June 1977): 283-310.
Swan,
Donald A. "The Distribution of ABO and Rhesus Blood
Groups Among South Mississippi Anglo-Saxon School Children."
Mankind Quarterly 18 (July-September 1977): 3-58.
[This is described as "a preliminary
report" of Swan's study of the structure of the Anglo-Saxon
population of southern Mississippi. It states that it was
undertaken by Roger Pearson's Institute for the Study of Man.]
[5
October 1977. The Pioneer Fund approves a $4,000 grant to
the IAAEE "for the reprint of a monograph on Heredity &
Eugenics." (Pioneer Fund's 1977 Form 990).]
Swan,
Donald. "Neue Befunde zur Rassenpsychologie der Europiden."
Neue Anthropologie (1977).
1978
Swan,
Donald A., and Garnett Hawkins. "The Dermatoglyphics
of South Mississippi Anglo-Saxon School Children: Part
I." Mankind Quarterly 18 (January-March 1978):
163-185.
Swan,
Donald A., and Garnett Hawkins. "The Dermatoglyphics
of South Mississippi Anglo-Saxon School Children: Part
II." Mankind Quarterly 18 (April-May 1978):
243-282.
Swan,
Donald A. "Racial Differences Are Not Just Skin Deep."
American Mercury, no. 528 (Spring 1978): 30-34.
[Largely reprinted from Swan, "Differences
in Races Are Not Just Skin Deep," Pulse (January 20,
1973): 20-21.]
[25
April 1978. The Pioneer Fund approves a $3,500 grant to
the IAAEE "for reprint of Prof. Osborne's article 'Fertility,
I.Q., & School Achievement'." (Pioneer Fund's 1978
Form 990. IAAEE's address remains PO Box 1588, Southern Station,
Hattiesburg.)]
Irsigler,
F.J. "Die Stellung des Homo Rhodesiensis in der Stammesgeschichte."
Mannus 44 (1978): 103-118.
[This includes a reference to Swan. See the notes
on Irsigler.]
Miszkiewicz,
Brunon. "Anthropologische Untersuchungen einiger angelsächsischer
Schulkindergruppen in den Vereinigten Staaten Amerikas (Mississippi)
1975-1976." Studies in Physical Anthropology 1 (1978):
69-85.
[14
September 1978. The Pioneer Fund approves a $5,000 grant
to the IAAEE "for reprint of a monograph on 'The Distribution
of the ABO- & Rh- Blood Groups among South Mississippi Anglo-Saxon
School Children'." (Pioneer Fund's 1978 Form 990).]
[9
December 1978. The Pioneer Fund approves a $5,000 grant
to the IAAEE "for research participation in the project 'The
Anthropological & Psychological Study of American Anglo-Saxon
School Children'." (Pioneer Fund's 1978 Form 990.)]
1979
[17
January 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $2,500
to the IAAEE for "studies of kinship correlations using anthropometric,
dermatoglyphic & behavioral data." (Pioneer Fund's
1979 Form 990.)]
[22
January 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $4,000
to the IAAEE for "dermatoglyphic studies of kinship correlations."
(Pioneer Fund's 1979 Form 990.)]
[3
March 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $5,000
to IAAEE for "the administration of intelligence & personality
tests to schoolchildren of the British Isles." (Pioneer Fund's
1979 Form 990.)]
[6
April 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $5,000
to IAAEE for "publication of monograph 'Twin Studies of Ability,
Personality, & Interest' by Dr. Robert C. Nichols." (Pioneer
Fund's 1979 Form 990.)]
[Spring
1979. Nouvelle Ecole, no. 31-32, p. 226. Half-page
ad for Mannus lists Swan.]
Engelstad,
David Stephen. "The Relation Between Family Size,
Ordinal Position and IQ in a Sample of South Mississippi School
Children." Mankind Quarterly 19 (March 1979):
193-213.
[This issue actually appears around July 1979.
Engelstad is graduate student of Ralph Scott. This paper
reports analysis of data collected as part of Swan's study.]
[7
August 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $4,500
to the IAAEE for "the scaling of socio-economic data obtained
in the Anglo-Saxon study." (Pioneer Fund's 1979 Form
990.)]
Miszkiewicz,
Brunon. "The Anthropological Analysis of Germanic
Cranial Series from the Merovingian Period According to the Approximation
Method of Adam Wanke." Mankind Quarterly 20 (September-December
1979): 36-77.
[Translated from German by Swan.]
[16
October 1979. The Pioneer Fund approves a grant of $4,500
to IAAEE for "an analysis of the relation between hair &
eye color & mental & behavioral traits." (Pioneer
Fund's 1979 Form 990.) This brings the total amount of the
Pioneer Fund's 1979 grants to the IAAEE to $25,500.]
Billig,
Michael. Psychology, Racism and Fascism. Birmingham,
1979.
[See references to Swan.]
1980
[29
January 1980. The Pioneer Fund approves a $10,000 grant
to the IAAEE for "studies of the head, body, and pigmentation
measures of British schoolchildren in connection with a comparative
study of British & southern Mississippi schoolchildren."
(1980 Form 990, which gives Swan's home address as address for
IAAEE.)]
[9
June 1980. The Pioneer Fund approves a $3,500 grant to the
IAAEE for "funding the analysis of data on test performance
and scholastic achievement as compared with data on family background
and socio-economic status obtained in the Anglo-Saxon study."]
Swan,
Donald A., Garnett Hawkins, and Betty Douglas. "The
Relationship Between ABO Blood Type and Factor of Personality
Among South Mississippi 'Anglo-Saxon' School Children."
Mankind Quarterly 20 (Spring-Summer 1980): 205-258.
[This issue actually appeared in August
1980.]
Boev,
Peter. "The Anthropological Origins of the Thracians."
Mankind Quarterly 20 (Spring-Summer 1980): 321-330.
[Translated from German by Swan. This is the last
item of Swan's to appear before his death.]
Schnapp,
Alain, and Jesper Svenbro. "Du Nazisme à 'Nouvelle
Ecole': Repères sur la prétendue Nouvelle droite."
Quaderni di Storia 6 (1980):
[A very good essay that is under-cited in the
English-language literature. Swan is named at p 113:
"Mais cette opération d'ouverture se conjugue avec la reprise
des vieux thèmes de la droite raciste. Le numéro 3 de 'Nouvelle
école,' par exemple, reprend un article de D.A. Swan, directeur
adjoint de 'Mankind Quarterly' sur 'le processus biologique de
la formation raciale'."]
Barnes,
Ian R. "The Pedigree of GRECE - II." Patterns
of Prejudice 14 (October 1980): 29-39.
[At page 36: " ... Nouvelle Ecole
puts forward similar notions of Nazi-style race-science."
A footnote here states: "See the article by D. Swan
introducing the work of Bertill Lundman, 'La 'Geographische Anthropologie'
de Bertil Lundman,' and 'A.R. Jensen repond aux questions de 'Nouvelle
Ecole'',Nouvelle Ecole, vol. 18, 1972, 75-81, all cited
in M. Billig, Psychology, Racism, and Fascism (Birmingham
1979), 24-25. The US representative of Nouvelle Ecole is
Donald Swan of Neue Anthropologie."]
[14
October 1980. The Pioneer Fund approves a $4,000 grant to
the IAAEE for "printing 4,000 copies of Prof Carleton Coon's
monograph entitled 'New Findings on the Origin of Races'."]
1981
[27
February 1981. The Pioneer Fund approves a $4,500 grant
to the IAAEE for "funding an analysis of the relation among
scholastic achievement, mental ability and personality factor
in context of data obtained in an Anglo-Saxon study, and preparing
a paper thereon to be submitted to the journal, Personality
and Individual Differences." (Pioneer Fund's 1981
Form 990. The address given for the IAAEE here is George
S Leonard's law office, 1629 K St NW, Suite 520, Washington DC.)]
[27
February 1981. The Pioneer Fund approves a $70,000 grant
to Arthur Jensen's Institute for the Study of Educational Differences
for, among other things, "analyses of data assembled by Donald
Swan, ... as more fully described in the Institute's research
proposal and budget for Oct 1, 1981 through Sept 30, 1982."
(Pioneer Fund's 1981 Form 990.)]
Taguieff,
Pierre-André. "L'Héritage Nazi: Des Nouvelles Droites
européennes à la littérature niant le génocide." Les
Nouveaux Cahiers, no. 64 (Spring 1981): 3-22.
[At page 14, Taguieff indicates that the bibliography
in Jacques de Mahieu's Précis de biopolitique (1969) includes
"références très 'Nouvelle Droite'," among which he
includes Swan.
At pages 14-15: "Un ensemble de
récents travaux ... dessine les connexions supra-nationales des
nouvelles droites intellectuelles. En compagnie de revues
surs comme Neue Anthropologie et The Mankind Quarterly,
Nouvelle Ecole, à laquelle il conviendrait d'adjoindre
par exemple Mannus (fondée en 1909 por l'archéologue nordiciste
G. Kossina, et où l'on retrouve D.A. Swan, de The M.Q.),
Genus ... ou Homo ..., n'offre au regard non préparé
que la face volontairement visible, le séduisant décor et la pointe
intellectuelle relativement souriante, dirigés par la stratégie
de la mise en acceptabilité, d'un appareil multidimensionnel qu'on
appellera conventionnellement, et faute de mieux, néo-nazi."]
[23
June 1981. Donald Swan dies at the age of 46 after surgery
in Forrest General Hospital in Hattiesburg.]
[July
1981. Nouvelle Ecole, no 36. This is the last issue
to list Swan as US correspondent. No 37 (Spring 82) lists
Dr. Robert John, an expatriate British anti-Semite and associate
of Roger Pearson. Eventually Paul Gottfried assumes the
position.]
"Donald
Swan (1935-1981)." Instauration 6 (November 1981):
20.
1982
Barnes,
Ian R. "Intellectual Processes on the French Far Right."
Patterns of Prejudice 16 (January 1982): 3-12.
[At page 6, on GRECE: "Other dubious
links exist: the GRECE contact in the USA, Donald Swan,
was co-author of a pamphlet entitled Race, Psychology and Education,
sent from a group called the 'International Association for the
Advancement of Ethnology and Eugenics of New York.' The
pamphlet concluded that Negroes are inferior in intelligence."]
"'New'
Anthropology." Patterns of Prejudice 16 (January
1982): 43-45.
[Swan is listed as a member of the Advisory Board
of Neue Anthropologie.]
"Nécrologie."
Nouvelle Ecole, no. 37 (Spring 1982): 158.
[Obituary of Swan.]
Moreau,
Patrick. "Revolution Conservatrice et Nouvelles Droites
Allemandes." Les Temps Modernes 39 (November 1982):
893-959.
[Refers to Swan.]
1983
Mehler,
Barry A. "The New Eugenics: Academic Racism in
the U.S. Today." Science for the People 15 (May-June
1983): 18-23.
[On page 20: "Among more recent [Pioneer
Fund grant] recipients have been ... the Institute for the Study
of Man, the recipient of ... $59,000 for two projects under the
direction of Donald Swann [sic] (see below) ...
"If you write to the IAAEE requesting
further information, they will send you a number of handsome reprints
which will help you understand the 'science' of raciology. Among
them are 'Race Shows in I.Q. Tests - Differences in Races are
not Just Skin Deep,' by Donald A. Swann [sic], secretary of the
IAAEE ... " An endnote here (p 23n16) cites "Donald
Swann, Race Shows in IQ Tests,' Pulse (January 27, 1973)
p. 18-19."
On p 20: "Several members of the IAAEE
Executive Committee (John R. Baker, C.D. Darlington and Donald
A. Swann [sic]) are also members of the Scientific Advisory Board
of the German eugenics journal, Neue Anthropologie."]
1987
[6
October 1987. Telephone interview with Ralph Scott.
Q: Can you describe the Mississippi research
briefly?
A: Well, there was a fellow by the name of
Donald Swan who had received a grant, as I recall. You know,
you're going back a long time. But to the best of my knowledge
he received a grant to study achievement profiles and he needed
someone to assist him and he wanted somebody who had some knowledge
of psychology and he asked me to make an inquiry, to put up, you
know, like people normally do, to put a sign up on the board,
and one of the students was interested in the position and, and
took it.
Q: Had you not previously known Professor Swan?
A: Ah, well, I'd known him, yeah, sure.
Q: I mean, had you known this previously to
the time he contacted you about this research project?
A: Uh, yes, Professor Swan stopped up in Iowa
with a, uh, a fellow from Poland who was visiting here under the
auspices of some government. But I tell you, I think I'm
going to close off now because I, I just feel that I, I don't
have a very good feeling about the way the media has handled some
of these issues ...
Q: Let me describe the basic areas that I have
not had a chance to go through, and then if you want to say good-bye,
that's fine. The reason I mention the Mississippi matter is because
Dr. Pearson had taught at Hattiesburg, at the University of Southern
Mississippi ...
A: Oh.
Q: ... and had been an associate of Dr. Swan
...
A: Uh-huh.
Q: ... and I wanted to determine whether you
had known him through that, or ...
A: No, no. I can honestly say that I
had not known that - I'm not even sure I knew Dr. Pearson then
- and I had not known that Dr. Pearson had been at Mississippi,
and I ...]
1988
Santiago,
Frank. "Rights Official Has Racial 'Purity' Links."
Des Moines Register (February 28, 1988), 1A, 9A.
[On page 9A, the story mentions the research project
on which Swan and Ralph Scott collaborated without mentioning
Swan by name: "The Pioneer grants to Scott, according
to The New York Times, included $6,000 to send a [University of
Northern Iowa] student to Hattiesburg, Miss., 'to administer,
score and assess physiological and psychological traits, as part
of 'The Anthropological and Psychological Study of American Anglo-Saxon
School Children'."]
[7
April 1988. Interview with John C. Eastman, director, Congressional
and Public Affairs, US Commission on Civil Rights, on the controversy
then surrounding Ralph Scott. Scott's work with Swan is
mentioned:
Q: ... the funding [that Scott received
from the Pioneer Fund] was for research in southern Mississippi
-- was for two things, one was for antibusing seminars ... the
other matter concerns funding for a research project that Scott
entered into in Mississippi with a man named Donald Swan, who
was at the time at the University of Southern Mississippi ...
A: It's my understanding that the grant
from the Pioneer Fund through the university was for the purposes
of busing seminars simply and there were a number of those seminars
held around the country. The seminars included scholars
of all racial and ethnic backgrounds and in fact Scott and the
others received commendation from the State of Massachusetts for
their efforts on that. And I don't know, I am unaware that
any of the money from that grant, or any other that Ralph received
...
Q: That would have been another grant,
I'm sure ...
A: The only grant that I know of that
Ralph received from the Pioneer Fund was for the busing seminars.
I don't know of the other one.
Q: And so did Donald Swan not even arise?
A: Other than the fact that it was in
the Des Moines article. It was not discussed at our meeting
in Des Moines, and Ralph and I have not discussed it at all and
he, when I asked him about the grant from the Pioneer Fund, the
only thing he ...
Q: He addressed the one that involved
the seminars?
A: Right. And it's my understanding
that's all that's involved.]
Mehler,
Barry A. "Ralph Scott's Curious Career: Rightist on
the Rights Panel." Nation (May 7, 1988):
640-642.
[On pages 640-41: "Scott received more
than $40,000 in some half-dozen separate grants from the Pioneer
Fund in the mid-1970s. These included a $6,000 grant to
send a University of Northern Iowa student to Hattiesburg, Mississippi,
to test the intelligence of 'Anglo-Saxon' schoolchildren.
The study was directed by the late Donald Swan, then assistant
professor of anthropology at the University of Southern Mississippi
at Hattiesburg. (When Swan, a longtime activist in the eugenics
movement, was arrested for mail fraud in April 1966, authorities
found Nazi paraphernalia, weapons, pictures of him with members
of George Lincoln Rockwell's American Nazi Party, and hundreds
of anti-Semitic, antiblack and anti-Catholic pamphlets in his
home.)"]
1989
[31
October 1989. Nine-page memo from William Frawley (professor
of linguistics, University of Delaware) to E.A. Trebant (president
of the university) on the Pioneer Fund. In a discussion
of Ralph Scott on page 4, Frawley refers to Swan: "$6,000
of Scott's original Pioneer Fund Money in the 1970's was to conduct
joint research with Donald Swan, then of the University of Southern
Mississippi, to test the intelligence of Anglo-Saxon school children.
Swan, it should be noted, supported by some $60,000 from the Pioneer
Fund (Mehler 1983), has written 'Racial Differences Are Not Just
Skin Deep' originally in the American Mercury 1978;
also distributed by the IAAEE: see more below; the title
of Swan's paper speaks for itself). In 1966, when Swan was
arrested for mail fraud in New York City, authorities found in
his house '... a loaded carbine, a high-powered range-finder,
clips for the carbine and 50 rounds of 45 caliber ammunition...
swords, Nazi flags... a German helmet [and] several photographs
of Swan with members of George Lincoln Rockwell's neo-Nazi organization'
(Walsh 1966, p. 5). These activities apparently recommended
Swan to receive subsequently over $50,000 in research money from
the Pioneer Fund (Mehler 1983)."
On page 5: "One of the main functions
of the IAAEE, through money from the Pioneer Fund, is to reprint
and distribute racist documents, e.g.,... Donald Swan's 'Racial
Differences Are Not Just Skin Deep'."]
"Pioneer
Fund Letter of William Frawley of 10/31/89." Unpublished
memorandum, November 15, 1989.
[On pp 12-13, there is a section on "Assistant
Professor Donald Swan":
"(Page 4) Donald Swan (deceased several
years ago, then on the faculty of the University of Southern Mississippi,
supervised in part a research comparison of white Mississippi
school children with white children of the same age at a location
in England where their ancestors had originated. Swan was
introduced to the Fund earlier by Dr. A. James Gregor, now a Professor
of Philosophy [sic] at the University of California. A professor
from a Polish university was also involved in the research to
do anthropometric measurements on both sets of children, and other
professors in the U.S. and U.K. participated. The research
question was to determine the differences which developed in the
two populations over the 250 years of separation, so as to measure
genetic drift.
"(Page 4) A trustee of the fund was informed
that Donald Swan's father, while in military service during World
War II, 'liberated' the collection of German military artifacts
which were found in Donald Swan's mother's home. Pioneer
knew of his conviction for mail fraud (ordering books with the
intention of avoiding payment). Pioneer knows nothing of
the photographs of Swan or the identity of other people in the
photographs."]
[22
November 1989. Three-page memo from Linda Gottfredson,
"More Information on the Pioneer Fund," to Ron Whittington
(assistant to the president, University of Delaware). On
page one:
"1. Donald Swan. On page
4 of his letter, Frawley states that authorities found in Donald
Swan's house various weapons along with 'Nazi flags...a German
helmet [and] several photographs of Swan with members of George
Lincoln Rockwell's neo-Nazi organization.' I have no knowledge
of the photograph. No one I have been able to contact knows
anything about it, let alone the identity of the people in it
or Swan's relation to them. I do know, however, that Frawley's
suggestion concerning the Nazi flags and helmet is utterly wrong.
The flags and helmet were souvenirs that his father had collected
while fighting against the Nazis in World War II, not anything
that Swan collected because of an alleged sympathy with neo-Nazis.
As with so many of his charges, Frawley here has turned the truth
inside-out. (See Addendum 1 on the Pioneer Fund, item 1.)"]
Mehler,
Barry. "Foundation for Fascism: the New Eugenics Movement
in the United States." Patterns of Prejudice
23 (Winter 1989-1990): 17-25.
[At page 21: "Ralph Scott ... received
over $40,000 from the Pioneer Fund in the mid-1970s. This
included a $6,000 grant to test 'Anglo-Saxon' schoolchildren in
a study directed by Donald Swan, Assistant Professor of Anthropology
at the University of [Southern Mississippi in] Hattiesburg, Mississippi.
When Swan was arrested in 1966 for mail fraud, authorities
found Nazi paraphernalia, swastika flags, weapons, pictures of
Swan with members of George Lincoln Rockwell's American Nazi Party
and hundreds of anti-Semitic, anti-black and anti-Catholic pamphlets
in his home."]
1994
Tucker,
William H. The Science and Politics of Racial Research.
Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1994.
[On page 263, Tucker writes: "Several
members of [Neue Anthropologie's] 'board of scientific
advisors' were also active in the German neo-Nazi party ... Another
board member was Donald Swan, also an editor and frequent contributor
to the Mankind Quarterly as well as a recipient of Pioneer
grants. According to the Nation, when Swan was arrested
for mail fraud in 1966, Nazi 'paraphernalia,' weapons, and stacks
of anti-Semitic, anti-black, and anti-Catholic pamphlets were
found in his home." Tucker cites Barry Mehler, "Rightist
on the Rights Panel," Nation (1988), p 644.]
1997
[17
June 1997. Robert A Gordon, "How Smart We Are
About What We Broadcast: An Open Letter to ABC News,"
addressed to seven people from ABC News, including Roone Arledge,
Peter Jennings, Bill Blakemore and Beth Nissan. This is
posted on the Pioneer Fund's web site at www.pioneerfund.org/ABCletter.html
. It is a very long (34,000 word) belated critique the report
on The Bell Curve and the Pioneer Fund on ABC's "World
News Tonight with Peter Jennings" of November 22, 1994.
Gordon refers to Donald Swan:
"One of the queries to which you demanded
response in a fax-letter of November 15th, 1994, signed by three
of you to Pioneer president Weyher, referred to a distasteful
1954 letter from perhaps the most obscure of the many persons
ever funded by Pioneer, one Donald Swan. A trail from the
letter leads through a reference to it from a newspaper in an
article published in 'The Nation in 1960, to an anti-Pioneer article
by Professor Mehler in 1989, titled 'Foundations from Fascism,'
which cited 'The Nation. Professor Mehler ... was thus a likely
resource concerning the existence of the Swan letter ...
"Long-deceased, Mr. Swan was an avid book
collector, if not, in one person's words, a 'bibliomaniac.'
He now of interest only because of his personal eccentricities,
such as his 1966 conviction for mail fraud for ordering three
books, oranges, grapefruits, and a fruit cake by mail without
intending to pay for same. These are used by Professor
Mehler and others to try to embarrass Pioneer, which, after Mr.
Swan's graduate training, funded him for entirely defensible scholarly
purposes. A balanced presentation would have to acknowledge
that Mr. Swan's professional credentials at the time showed him
sufficiently qualified to merit such funding and his professional
publications, as well as at least some of his personal ones, display
considerable knowledge for their time. Laypersons who met
Mr. Swan during his lifetime recall him as impressively learned
in scientific and scientific matters, and he is known to have
corresponded widely with scholars around the world. He had
been introduced to Pioneer by someone who went on to a career
as a respected professor at a major university.
"Mr. Swan's 1954 letter, until November
1994 unknown to all except those who maintain dossiers on such
matters, expressed an intellectual infatuation with Fascism.
The letter was also flashed before me ambush-style during my interview
on camera (this portion was not broadcast), where I was given
no opportunity to examine it adequately or learn more of its context.
Like me, Mr. Weyher was challenged, in your fax-letter on November
15th, 1994, to respond to their brief quotations from the Swan
letter, which you conveniently purported to him had been published
in 'the white-supremacist newspaper, 'Expose [sic]' (November
15, 1994, letter from Mr.Blakemore, Ms. Mendez, and Mr. Oetgen
to Mr. Weyher).
"On November 16th, Mr. Weyher replied
to ABC News that he was responding to various charges detailed
in that letter, but some, such as Mr. Swan's letter, were new
to him and so he requested documentation. On November 18th,
1994, Mr. Blakemore, Ms. Mendez, and Mr. Oetgen, after being prodded
twice by fax and telephone, informed Mr. Weyher by fax, 'It is
not our practice to pass along documentation we have collected
in the course of preparing a news report. If you have information
that disproves or casts doubt upon any of our assertions, please
provide that information to us.' Clearly, ABC News was engaging
in a one-way flow of information distinctly different from the
manner in which scientific issues are customarily resolved, while
purporting to deal with matters of scientific importance and the
work of scientists. Without knowledge of the sources of
the allegations, many of which were vaguely or tendentiously worded,
one would be helpless to respond adequately. The ambushers
seemed interested only in ascertaining what Mr. Weyher might be
able to respond to effectively on extremely short notice, in order
to avoid being ambushed themselves by correct information.
Under the guise of granting a target an opportunity to respond,
the media reconnoiter the target without permitting themselves
to be felt out in return...
"One can anticipate that ABC News would
justify such questions as the one about Mr. Swan, which in relation
to scientific issues is a mere side show, for a program on The
Bell Curve by maintaining that the public had a legitimate
interest in the answers, but if that is so, why must the questions
be raised in such a peculiarly unfair manner? ...
"Subsequent cross-checking by Pioneer
and me revealed that Mr. Swan's sophomoric letter had been written
by him at age 19, precisely the usual age of a college sophomore.
Continued checking since the broadcast corrects your allegation
... that Expose, a small-circulation monthly initially
unfamiliar to any of us, was a 'white supremacist' publication.
Quite the contrary, 'Expose was an active and courageous defender
of racial justice in its time, published and edited by the well-known
Lyle Stuart, a member at the time of the American Civil Liberties
Union (ACLU).
"The February, 1952, issue of 'Expose'
carried an article by the ACLU's Arthur Garfield Hays, 'Guilt
By Association,' which I heartily commend to your attention.
Who knows, perhaps a 'Donald Swan' or two will turn up in the
history of your organization ... Had you read even as far beyond
Mr. Swan's letter as the letter adjoining it on the same page,
you might have noticed that the second letter took 'Exposé to
task for being 'pro-Negro.'
"Mr. Swan's incunabular letter had been
promted by a four-part series of articles in 'Exposé' entitled,
'I Am An American Fascist,' which this free-thinking, anti-censorship
newspaper ran to allow its readers to see for themselves the mentality
of a self-professed American Fascist, one H. Keith Thompson.
Your carelessness in assuming an ideological connection between
Mr. Swan's letter and the publication in which it appeared is
not dissimilar to your disposition to associate Mr. Swan's quirky
and quite unpleasant personal views with Pioneer and those who
have recieved Pioneer grants. Carried to its logical conclusion,
such reasoning would have us all suspected, in view of Mr. Swan's
later conviction, of mail fraud too.
"One purpose behind ambush questions is
to convey the impression that the journalist knows more about
a person being interviewed than the person thinks the journalist
knows. Understandable surprise at a totally unexpected question
can register on camera as guilty knowledge. But Donald Swan's
letter in Expose was as obscure to us as Paul de Man's
early anti-Semitic writings were to his friends and literary critics
... Unlike Mr. Swan, Professor de Man was a major figure.
Nevertheless, no one has accused Professor de Man's followers
of anything worse than practicing and promoting a foolish form
of scholarship. Instead of confronting us with vile ambush
insinuations that we are ill-prepared to answer on the spot, you
ought to state openly exactly what lessons you believe that Mr.
Swan's personal beliefs hold for Pioneer and the hundred or so
researchers it has funded, so that, once explicit, the absurdity
of those lessons, and your complicity in politically correct slander,
will be plain for all to see.
"The unspoken assumption that a funding
source should be held accountable for the personal politics of
its recipients has embedded within it the thought that prospective
grantees should be scrutinized as to their political beliefs,
and funding decisions made accordingly ... "]
Revised
June 25, 1998