Ferris Homepage

 Letters to the Jim Crow Museum

Where is the Line to be Drawn?

Good Morning, I hope I'm not over staying my welcome with another e-mail. Maybe I should just go straight to the "Letters" section in the future. However, I wanted to tell you that yesterday evening - after all the thought provoking reading and our e-mails - it all kept churning around in my head; and as I had to drive down into Appalachia for a work assignment - about a five hour round trip - I was left with a lot of time in the car to think about the Jim Crow Museum, stereotyping and negative caricatures in general. Anyway, it occur to me that maybe I had not asked myself the right questions, i.e. where is the line to be drawn; is there a ever a legitimate usage of and/or place for the derogatory, the negative caricatures and stereotyping outside of a teaching environment such as your museum.

And my original question about Faulkner seemed a little dumb as, yes, the "Arts" are a teaching vehicle and there should be legitimate usages, but making the call, and as to who can make it and in what context - that gets tricky. The current controversy over the use of the N word swirls around us everyday (last night black comedian Eddie Griffin was stopped in the middle of his routine). Is that conversation, an internal "Family" affair on which I should keep my opinions to myself? ... But I digress.

Ok - so when I arrived back home last night around midnight I was wired from the road and decided to drink a beer and watch TV and as serendipity would have it the first thing I clicked on was one of my all time favorite movies: the great old cult classic; a film I truly felt was full of coolness and clever humor, The Blues Brothers. I've seen it at least a couple of dozen times, and even if I saw it at a dozen times more, I still wouldn't get tired of it.

However, this time I immediately flashed back on the thoughts, which had commanded my attention all day. I saw the film in a new way and was not at all sure if I liked what I was feeling. There was James Brown as Reverend Cleophus; Cab Calloway as Curtis the janitor who was Jake and Elwood's mentor and lives in the basement of an orphanage; Ray Charles who runs a pawn shop called Ray's Music Exchange and Howlin' Wolf as street musician; the interaction between Aretha Franklin who runs a Sole Cafe and her "man" Matt 'Guitar' Murphy; band member Willie 'Too Big' Hall; the Neo-Nazis from the American Socialist White People's Party (LOL); the Good Ol' Boys and the red-necks at Bob's Country Bunker and the Jewish booking agent Steve Lawrence as Maury Sline - all stock stereotypical characters.

Where's the sliding scale on this? Is there one? Is it just a really cool repackaging (30 years ago) of the same old crap; did the caricatures Archie Bunker and George Jefferson really accomplish anything?

This morning when I woke up, I was not as sure as I was 24 hours that I could draw the distinction between the legitimate and the perverse - if such a thing exists, other than to hope that I'll know it when I see it; that I can recognize the underlying intent and judge it accordingly.


-- September 6, 2007



YouTube  Twitter

About the Founder

Other Stereotypes


Quick Links

Speaker Info
Upcoming Talks

Native Americans
Mexican Americans
Museum Staff
Partners and Sponsors
Other Collections
Question of the Month
Jim Crow Museum
Copyright © 2014 - All Rights Reserved - Ferris State University