|
From Developing and Using Tests Effectively by Jacobs and Chase 1992
Positives for Using True-False
Questions
-
True-false can sample many more bits of information in a
given time period than any other type of test format.
-
The greater number of questions increases the reliability
of the test.
-
Research does indicate true-false testing is sufficiently
reliable and valid for periodic use in classroom testing.
Negatives of True-False
Questions
-
It can be difficult to write true-false questions that
avoid ambiguous statements without making the answer obvious.
-
Writing true or false statements that have no exceptions
is problematic.
-
Guessing on the part of the student (50-50 chance)
-
Students can also make educated guesses increasing their
odds beyond 50-50 but still not know the answer outright.
Writing True-False Questions
Make it clear where the answers are to be placed and what sign (T or F) or
word is to be used. Avoid using a plus (+) and minus (-) sign as the minus can
be made into a plus easily.
Avoid the use of specific determiners (all, never, always). These
words are a sign of false answers.
Avoid the use of qualifying terms (sometimes, usually, typically).
These words are a sign of true answers.
Avoid the use of indefinite terms denoting degree or amount (a long time
ago, a very large part). These words are ambiguous and thus make the answer
into a debate
Don’t leave questions up to interpretation
Example:
POORLY WRITTEN: In his study of AIDS, Dr. Wye found that many of
those who contracted the HIV virus were exposed through the use of drug
needles that had been used by an infected person.
BETTER VERSION: In his study of AIDS, Dr. Wye found that many (over
20 percent) …infected person.
State the true-false statements as positive declarative sentences, stated as
simply as possible.
Assessing students’ knowledge is the goal, not their ability to interpret
complex sentences.
Use of Compound Sentences
Compound sentences can be used by stating a condition first and then followed
by an explanation.
Example:
Because the combustion of gasoline creates gases that pollute the air, cars
produce more pollutants at fifty miles per hour than at thirty miles per hour
This form of question can test students at a higher level of thinking.
Using True-False to Ask Higher Level Thinking
Questions
Using propositional logic. Using the "if-then" approach.
Example:
Under the current money policy of the Federal Reserve Bank, the prime rate is
.09 and the inflation rate is .04. The gross national product is down.03, and
the unemployment rate is 7 percent. A slow down in the economy is taking place.
True-False— if the Federal Reserve reduces the prime rate, the inflation rate
is expected to rise.
True-False— if the gross national product goes up and the other indicators
stay the same, the Dow Jones average will probably respond by going up.
This type of questioning allows for writing several T-F questions related to
the same situation or proposition.
Problem Solving Approach
Example
Last night John bought a used car. This morning it would not start. John
begins to search for the possible causes of the car’s failure to start. Decide
whether each statement is or is not a plausible reason for the car not starting.
T-F The carburetor may be malfunctioning
T-F The exhaust manifold may be loose
T-F The battery may be discharged
T-F The car may be out of gasoline
Use Multiple True-False Items
Example:
The Boston Tea Party (1773) was
1. T-F Actually carried out by Indians
2. T-F Planned as a revolt against taxes
3. T-F Occured because the tea market in America was overstocked and prices
were falling |